BEATNIK INDUSTRIES, a BREAD
BOWL of IMAGES and GENERIC ASPIRIN

  • HOME
  • COLOPHON
  • RSS FEED

A 1981 Interview with Garry Winogrand on the Irrelevance of Source Material

February 10th, 2010  |  published in Photographed.

photographed in Tokyo, Japan on September 4, 2007


If you don’t like “street photographer,” how do you respond to that other tiresome phrase, “snapshot aesthetic”?

I knew that was coming. That’s another stupidity. The people who use the term don’t even know the meaning. They use it to refer to photographs they believe are loosely organized, or casually made, whatever you want to call it. Whatever terms you like. The fact is, when they’re talking about snapshots they’re talking about the family album picture, which is one of the most precisely made photographs. Everybody’s fifteen feet away and smiling. The sun is over the viewer’s shoulder. That’s when the picture is taken, always. It’s one of the most carefully made photographs that ever happened. People are just dumb. They misunderstand.

That’s an interesting point, particularly coming from someone who takes — or rather, composes and then snaps — lightning-fast shots.

I’ll say this, I’m pretty fast with a camera when I have to be. However, I think it’s irrelevant. I mean, what if I said that every photograph I made was set up? From the photograph, you can’t prove otherwise. You don’t know anything from the photograph about how it was made, really. But every photograph could be set up. If one could imagine it, one could set it up. The whole discussion is a way of not talking about photographs.

From Visions and Images: American Photographers on Photography by Barbaralee Diamonstein. Published by Rizoli, New York, 1981.

Responses can be Left Here.

 

Recently Noticed

  • @samuelrhodes Been using them for the last five years. Great stuff. in reply to samuelrhodes 1 week ago
  • If you were thinking of tap-dancing on boards, check them first for slippery-ness. #lifetips 1 week ago
  • @iamhanakim I, for one, welcome our new Twitty overlords. in reply to iamhanakim 2 weeks ago
  • @iamhanakim Didn't you say you were overeating? Comeuppance. in reply to iamhanakim 2 weeks ago
  • Pro tip: Order ahead at #Grimaldi #039;s, skip the line and make tourists angry. 2 weeks ago
  • @samuelrhodes Smoothies ain't food, son. There's your problem. in reply to samuelrhodes 2 weeks ago
  • 'We should have shotguns for this.' Filed under 'Pulp Fiction quotes applicable to the current work situation.' 2 weeks ago
  • Inebriation might be better than the original Inception. http://bit.ly/amMBd7 3 weeks ago
  • What happens when you own a stock that's delisted? Interesting situation. 3 weeks ago
  • Hometown Cincy feed for the #Bengals game. Beechmont Honda! 3 weeks ago
  • Pet peeve: Getting to work and finding the place still locked. 2010-08-12
  • Dear Chase: Do not use 'Dueling Banjos' for a TV spot unless Deliverance comparisons are expected and wanted. 2010-08-11
  • Surprise #Bengals preseason game on NBC. 2010-08-08
  • Reason number six I'm sorry about missing #Lollapalooza My buddy @DaveSandell just hung out with Maeby Fünke. 2010-08-07
  • Kingswood for brunch. Amazing eggs but don't offend the locals. 2010-08-07
  • Moved to NYC, so very, very sad to be missing Midwest fun at #lollapalooza 2010-08-06
  • Do not underestimate a New York tourist's appetite for free. #moma 2010-08-06
  • Roger still gets the best lines. #madmen 2010-08-01
  • Despite calling NFL stats 'sabermetrics,' a cost-benefit analysis of misbehaving Bengals players that's worth a damn. http://bit.ly/99BGfs 2010-08-01
  • What do the arcane symbols they paint on the street mean? I think it's some sort of hobo code. 2010-08-01
  • More updates...


© 2010 and earlier BEATNIK INDUSTRIES.
Powered by WordPress using Industries Grid, an adaptation of the Gridline Lite theme. If you're interested, there's a colophon for more information.